The Detroit Lions’ 2025 NFL Draft class has stirred a mix of optimism and scrutiny among football analysts and fans. While the team addressed key positional needs, some selections have been questioned for their value and timing. Here’s a comprehensive overview of what experts are saying about Detroit’s newest group of rookies.
First-Round Pick: Tyleik Williams, DT, Ohio State
The Lions used their first-round pick to select Tyleik Williams, a powerful defensive tackle from Ohio State. This move was largely seen as a strategic attempt to reinforce the interior of the defensive line, especially after injuries and underperformance plagued that unit in 2024. NFL Network awarded the pick a B+, highlighting Williams’ run-stopping ability and physical presence in the trenches. However, concerns were raised about his limited pass-rushing upside. Pro Football Focus and the Associated Press echoed these sentiments, noting that while Williams can anchor the run defense, he may need further development to become a consistent three-down threat.
Day 2 Picks: Isaac TeSlaa and Concerns About Value
The Lions’ second and third-round selections received mixed reviews, particularly the choice of wide receiver Isaac TeSlaa in the third round. Analysts were surprised by this pick, especially since TeSlaa was ranked 149th on ESPN’s big board at the time and several more polished receivers were still available. Mel Kiper Jr. expressed skepticism about the pick, while NFL Network gave the Lions a C grade for Day 2, suggesting that the front office may have reached too far for need over value.
Strengthening the Offensive Line: Tate Ratledge and Miles Frazier
To shore up protection for quarterback Jared Goff and improve the running game, Detroit drafted two offensive linemen: Tate Ratledge and Miles Frazier. Both come with SEC experience and the versatility to play multiple positions along the line. With veteran guard Kevin Zeitler no longer with the team and Graham Glasgow aging, these picks were viewed positively. Frazier, in particular, brings flexibility, which could be vital in case of injuries during the season. Pride of Detroit praised these selections as “quietly smart moves” that could pay off long-term.
Late-Round Steal: Ahmed Hassanein, EDGE, Boise State
In the sixth round, the Lions took a flyer on edge rusher Ahmed Hassanein from Boise State. Hassanein has a compelling background—he started playing football in 2019 after moving from Egypt, and despite being relatively new to the sport, he tallied 22 sacks over his final two college seasons. Analysts have lauded his drive, character, and upside, with some even calling him a potential “Dan Campbell guy.” His story and work ethic make him a fan favorite, and he could develop into a valuable rotational pass rusher.
Undrafted Free Agents Worth Watching
Detroit has a strong history of finding impactful undrafted free agents, and this year’s crop may continue that trend. Two names to watch are wide receiver Jackson Meeks from Syracuse and tight end Caden Prieskorn from Ole Miss. Meeks has special teams experience, which increases his chances of making the final roster. Prieskorn, who received a sizable signing bonus, could offer depth behind Sam LaPorta. Analysts from Pride of Detroit and other outlets have pointed out that Detroit’s UDFA class often includes at least one eventual contributor, and 2025 may be no different.
Overall Draft Grades and Final Thoughts
The Lions’ 2025 draft class received grades ranging from C- to B-. While the first-round pick of Tyleik Williams was generally well-received, the mid-round selections—especially Isaac TeSlaa—were more controversial. Still, Detroit addressed several key areas, including the defensive line, offensive guard spots, and wide receiver depth. The success of this class will largely hinge on how quickly players like Williams and Ratledge adapt to the NFL and whether any of the late-round or undrafted prospects emerge as reliable contributors.
In conclusion, while not universally praised, the Detroit Lions’ 2025 draft class shows a clear effort to build a tougher, more complete roster. The coming months of training camp and preseason action will reveal just how impactful this rookie group can be.
