The Miami Dolphins are currently facing a quarterback dilemma, especially with their star player, Tua Tagovailoa, recovering from a concussion. While they can’t afford to make a risky and expensive move, they are in search of a reliable backup who can step in when needed. Bill Barnwell from ESPN recently suggested a feasible solution that could benefit the team without breaking the bank. His proposal involves trading a 2025 fourth-round pick to the Carolina Panthers in exchange for Bryce Young, the 2023 NFL Draft’s No. 1 overall pick.
Although the Panthers have publicly stated they are not interested in moving Young, their decision to bench him may indicate otherwise. Barnwell’s argument hinges on this, stating that the Panthers’ actions speak louder than words. Trading for Young would provide the Dolphins with a capable backup, one who fits well into coach Mike McDaniel’s run-pass-option offensive system. Young’s skill set aligns with Miami’s needs, making this a potentially beneficial move for both teams.
The Dolphins’ uncertainty at quarterback stems from Tagovailoa’s injury history. While he is expected to return this season, his multiple concussions have raised questions about his long-term future in the sport. With a clear gap in their backup quarterback options, acquiring Young could provide the Dolphins with a high-upside replacement who may even grow into a starting role if Tagovailoa’s situation worsens. Given the Dolphins’ current roster and aspirations, bringing in a promising player like Young could stabilize their quarterback depth.
Financially, the deal makes sense for Miami. Bryce Young is still playing under his rookie contract, which spans four years and is valued at $38 million, including a team option for the 2027 season. However, thanks to the contract’s structure, much of that money has already been paid out, leaving the Dolphins responsible for just $10.7 million through 2026. This makes Young a cost-effective investment for a player who could potentially evolve into a key figure in the team’s future.
Overall, this trade would provide Miami with a solid backup plan for their quarterback position without overspending. It’s a strategic move that addresses both short-term needs and long-term possibilities, offering the Dolphins a chance to groom a potential future star while also securing depth behind Tagovailoa. Whether the Panthers are willing to part with Young remains to be seen, but for Miami, it could be the perfect opportunity to shore up a critical position.
