Steve Brookstein, the first winner of The X Factor, has recently opened up about his tumultuous experience on the show, shedding light on the “vindictive” treatment he faced from Simon Cowell and others.
In a candid interview, he reflected on how the sudden shift from celebrity status to obscurity left him feeling abandoned and unsupported. Brookstein emphasized that while contestants receive significant attention during the competition, they often face a harsh reality once the cameras stop rolling1.
Brookstein’s criticisms extend to the show’s aftercare policies, which he claims are inadequate. He described how contestants are initially showered with support but are abruptly left to navigate their newfound fame alone.
This lack of preparation for the media scrutiny can be devastating,
particularly for young artists like Liam Payne, who faced similar pressures during his rise to stardom13. Brookstein believes that proper support systems are essential for contestants to manage their mental health post-show.
In his remarks, Brookstein recounted a particularly harsh moment involving Sharon Osbourne, who publicly insulted him during rehearsals.
This incident exemplified the toxic environment that can exist behind the scenes of reality television. He recalled feeling demoralized and questioned his worth as an artist after such public humiliation1. His experiences highlight the darker side of fame that often goes unaddressed in the entertainment industry.
Despite these challenges, Brookstein has continued to pursue his music career and has even written a book detailing his journey. In Getting Over the X,
he explores the emotional toll of winning a show that ultimately failed to support him in the long run. He describes his battle with feelings of bitterness and resentment towards Cowell and The X Factor, which he believes prioritized entertainment over genuine talent3.
Brookstein’s story resonates with many former contestants who have faced similar struggles in their careers.
The recent tragic loss of Liam Payne has reignited discussions about mental health and support within the entertainment industry. Cowell himself expressed deep sorrow over Payne’s passing, reflecting on the pressures young artists face in a high-stakes environment2. This context underscores the need for change in how reality shows handle contestant welfare.
As Brookstein continues to share his experiences, he hopes to raise awareness about the importance of mental health support for reality TV participants. His journey serves as a reminder that while fame can be alluring, it often comes with significant challenges that require careful management and understanding from those at the helm of these productions.
