Toronto Maple Leafs president and CEO Keith Pelley has confirmed that the organization has no immediate plans to part ways with team president Brendan Shanahan, putting to rest — at least for now — speculation about potential front-office shakeups following another disappointing postseason.
Pelley, who took over as Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment CEO earlier in 2024, addressed the media this week and was asked directly about Shanahan’s future after the team’s first-round playoff exit. Despite growing frustration among the fan base and pressure from local media, Pelley maintained that the organization remains committed to its current leadership structure.
“Brendan Shanahan is still a critical part of our hockey operations,” Pelley said. “There are no current plans to make any changes in that regard. We’re focused on evaluating all aspects of the team’s performance, but Brendan continues to play a central role in that process.”
Shanahan, who has served as president of the Maple Leafs since 2014, has overseen a decade-long rebuild and a consistent playoff contender. However, postseason success has eluded the team during his tenure. Despite multiple trips to the playoffs and a talented core led by Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander, the Maple Leafs have failed to make a deep run, often exiting in the first round.
The most recent loss — a Game 7 overtime defeat to the Boston Bruins — reignited calls for accountability at the highest levels. Critics have questioned the long-term direction of the franchise and whether the “Shanaplan,” as it was once called, has run its course.
Pelley, however, emphasized the importance of continuity and thoughtful decision-making over reactionary changes. He noted that the organization is conducting a thorough postseason review and that all departments are being evaluated. Still, he stressed that stability can be an asset in a league where quick fixes rarely lead to sustained success.
“Of course we’re disappointed. Everyone — from the players to the coaches to the front office — wants more,” Pelley said. “But that doesn’t mean you abandon your principles or your people at the first sign of adversity. Brendan brings experience, leadership, and a long-term vision that’s still very valuable to us.”
Shanahan’s tenure has not been without accomplishments. He was instrumental in hiring general managers Lou Lamoriello, Kyle Dubas, and most recently Brad Treliving. He also played a key role in modernizing the franchise’s hockey operations and shaping the roster around elite young talent. Under his leadership, the Leafs have consistently been among the NHL’s most competitive regular-season teams.
Still, the lack of playoff breakthroughs continues to be the dark cloud hanging over the Shanahan era. Some fans have pointed to player contract structures, coaching hires, and trade decisions as areas where the organization has fallen short. The pressure to win in Toronto — a hockey-mad market with the longest Stanley Cup drought in the NHL — is unlike anywhere else.
Pelley acknowledged that expectation and assured fans that their frustrations are heard. But he also called for patience and trust in the process, reiterating that change for the sake of change isn’t the answer.
“We’re not going to chase headlines. We’re going to make smart decisions based on where we want to go and how we get there,” he said. “That process is ongoing, and Brendan Shanahan is part of that.”
As for what comes next, all eyes will be on the Leafs’ offseason strategy. With potential roster moves looming, the future of head coach Sheldon Keefe still uncertain, and contract situations involving key players like Mitch Marner potentially reaching a tipping point, the pressure on the front office — including Shanahan — remains intense.
For now, however, Keith Pelley has made it clear: Brendan Shanahan still has the confidence of ownership and will be a leading voice in shaping what comes next for one of the NHL’s most scrutinized franchises.
